Really? You both think seeing the function signature a second time at the definition is 'noisy' when compared to massive blocks of arbitrarily indented function body code consuming the entire class definition, and completely breaking up your code window?

A few function bodies and you can't see anything anymore. You have to scroll miles to get an overview of the class, and try and remember each function header along the way as you scroll by; you can never digest it cleanly in one place.

My memory's not that good... So you end up scrolling up and down and up and down and up and down, and then inevitably, get off your arse, walk over, and interrupt the guy that wrote it.

That's a waste of my time, it's a waste of their time, and in an office environment, it's a waste of money.

So, I find it extremely useful being able to see the members and functions available listed in a row all together. I can quickly gather a fairly complete mental picture.

Everyone on the weekend agreed with me, none of us could immediately understand the classes we were working with. Productivity being the key element in our exercise, and it demonstrably impacted our productivity.

But whatever. I just threw it in there because it was a recurring topic, and I thought it was worth mentioning.