hi,

It seems that template members of a class are always public.

having a class like:
class Test
{
  private:
    int x;
    template test(T)
    {
	void test(T t) {x= 100;}
    }
  public:
    int getX() {return x;}
}

and calling:
Test t = new Test;
t.test();

prints 100 instead of saying that the member test is not accessable. Is it not possible to get private template members with D?

On 01.05.2011 13:37, hunt0r wrote:
> hi,
>
> It seems that template members of a class are always public.
>
> having a class like:
> class Test
> {
>    private:
>      int x;
>      template test(T)
>      {
> 	void test(T t) {x= 100;}
>      }
>    public:
>      int getX() {return x;}
> }
>
> and calling:
> Test t = new Test;
> t.test();
>
> prints 100 instead of saying that the member test is not accessable.
> Is it not possible to get private template members with D?
It's not clear if you are calling it from separate module or from the same one. The access protection in D is module level, meaning you can access private members of the class in the same module.
There are some known bugs about it: http://d.puremagic.com/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=3108
<http://d.puremagic.com/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=314>

-- 
Dmitry Olshansky

I was calling it from another module:
in file Test.d:
class Test
{
  private:
    int x;
    void testNonTemplate()
    {
    }
    template test()
    {
	void test() {x= 100;}
    }
  public:
    int getX() {return x;}
}
In file main.d:
import Test;
Test t = new Test;
t.test(); /*ok*/
t.testNonTemplate(); /*error*/
writeln(t.getX()); /* prints 100 */

I am using dmd 2.052

On 01.05.2011 16:38, hunt0r wrote:
> I was calling it from another module:
> in file Test.d:
> class Test
> {
>    private:
>      int x;
>      void testNonTemplate()
>      {
>      }
>      template test()
>      {
> 	void test() {x= 100;}
>      }
>    public:
>      int getX() {return x;}
> }
> In file main.d:
> import Test;
> Test t = new Test;
> t.test(); /*ok*/
> t.testNonTemplate(); /*error*/
> writeln(t.getX()); /* prints 100 */
>
> I am using dmd 2.052
Then it's definitely a bug, it might be a duplicate report but it I suggest to file it anyway.
It sill fails on my almost newest DMD from github.

-- 
Dmitry Olshansky

On 05/01/2011 03:15 PM, Dmitry Olshansky wrote:
> On 01.05.2011 16:38, hunt0r wrote:
>> I was calling it from another module:
>> in file Test.d:
>> class Test
>> {
>> private:
>> int x;
>> void testNonTemplate()
>> {
>> }
>> template test()
>> {
>> void test() {x= 100;}
>> }
>> public:
>> int getX() {return x;}
>> }
>> In file main.d:
>> import Test;
>> Test t = new Test;
>> t.test(); /*ok*/
>> t.testNonTemplate(); /*error*/
>> writeln(t.getX()); /* prints 100 */
>>
>> I am using dmd 2.052
> Then it's definitely a bug, it might be a duplicate report but it I
> suggest to file it anyway.
> It sill fails on my almost newest DMD from github.
>

Probably this one: http://d.puremagic.com/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=2775

-- 
Mike Wey