July 08, 2013 C++ template mangling DMC vs VS | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ||||
I've tried to compile next code:
struct Goo
{
template<class X>
struct Boo
{
template<class Y>
struct Xoo
{
Y* v;
};
X* v;
};
void bar2(Boo<void>::Xoo<int> arg1);
};
void Goo::bar2(Goo::Boo<void>::Xoo<int> arg1)
{
}
Visual Studio mangle Goo::bar2 as
"?bar2@Goo@@QAEXU?$Xoo@H@?$Boo@X@1@@Z"
It's expected:
?$Xoo@H@ : - ::Xoo<int>
?$Boo@X@ : - ::Boo<void>
1 : - Goo (saved early)
DMC mangle Goo::bar2 as
"?bar2@Goo@@QAEXU?$Xoo@?$Boo@Goo@X@Goo@H@?$Boo@Goo@X@1@@Z"
?$Xoo@?$Boo@Goo@X@Goo@H@ :- ::Xoo<int>
?$Boo@Goo@X@ :- ::Boo<void>
1 : - Goo (saved early)
Ergo: DMC writes all parent names for each part of templated name.
Is this behaviour expected and desirable or it is bug?
(I'm writing C++ mangler for DMD now and I need to know: should I create special cases for DMC and VS or I can use VS mangling scheme and wait when this issue will be fixed in DMC?)
| ||||
July 08, 2013 Re: C++ template mangling DMC vs VS | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ||||
Posted in reply to IgorStepanov | Also: VS mangler substitute repeated templated parts of name, DMC not.
EG:
void gun(P1::Mem<int>, P2::Mem<int>){}
VS: "?gun@@YAXU?$Mem@H@P1@@U1P2@@@Z"
Attention: VS has substituted second Mem<int> with "1"
DMC: "gun@@YAXU?$Mem@P1@H@P1@@U?$Mem@P2@H@P2@@@"
| |||
Copyright © 1999-2021 by the D Language Foundation
Permalink
Reply